Advice

Stop Overthinking and Start Deciding: The Real Reasons You're Paralysed by Choice

I once knew a bloke who spent three months deciding which coffee machine to buy for his office. Three months! By the time he made his choice, two of his best staff had already quit from caffeine withdrawal. That's the thing about indecisiveness – it doesn't just cost you money, it costs you opportunities, relationships, and sometimes your sanity.

Related Articles:
Managing Difficult Conversations | Time Management

Here's what I've learnt after 18 years of consulting with businesses across Melbourne, Sydney, and Brisbane: indecisiveness isn't actually about lacking information. It's about fear dressed up as perfectionism. And it's killing your productivity faster than a Monday morning team meeting.

The Hidden Cost of "Just One More Day"

Most business leaders think they're being thorough when they delay decisions. Wrong. You're being expensive. Every day you spend "gathering more data" is a day your competitor is moving ahead, your team is losing momentum, and your opportunities are walking out the door.

I had a client in Perth – let's call him Dave – who spent six weeks deciding whether to hire a new sales manager. The position was bleeding revenue daily. When I asked him what additional information he needed, he couldn't answer. He was just scared of making the wrong choice.

Here's the brutal truth: there's no such thing as a perfect decision. There are only decisions you make and decisions you don't. And in business, not deciding IS deciding – you're choosing to stay stuck.

The 73% Rule That Changed Everything

Research shows that 73% of successful business decisions are made with incomplete information. The remaining 27% who wait for "all the facts" usually miss the boat entirely. I learnt this the hard way when I passed on acquiring a smaller consultancy because I wanted to "analyse it properly." Someone else snapped it up within the week, and it's now worth three times what I could have paid.

The key isn't having perfect information; it's having enough information to make a reasonable choice and the confidence to adjust course if needed.

Why Your Brain Sabotages Your Decisions

Your brain isn't designed for the modern business world. It's still operating on ancient software that kept our ancestors alive by avoiding risks. Every time you face a decision, your prehistoric brain whispers: "What if this goes wrong? What if there's a better option? What if, what if, what if?"

This is where emotional intelligence training becomes crucial. You need to recognise when fear is masquerading as careful consideration.

I see this constantly in Brisbane boardrooms – smart, capable executives frozen by analysis paralysis. They'll commission another report, schedule another meeting, seek another opinion. Anything to avoid the responsibility of actually choosing.

The Real Secret: Good Enough Is Good Enough

In 2019, I made one of my best business decisions in about 15 minutes. I was offered a partnership opportunity with a training provider in Adelaide. Instead of spending weeks analysing every angle, I asked myself three simple questions:

Does this align with my values?
Can I afford the worst-case scenario?
Will I regret not trying more than I'll regret trying and failing?

The answers were yes, yes, and absolutely. That partnership has generated over $400k in revenue and some of my most rewarding professional relationships.

The Decision-Making Framework That Actually Works

Here's the system I use with clients who struggle with indecisiveness:

Set a deadline. Not "sometime next week" but "by 3pm Thursday." Decisions expand to fill the time you give them. Artificial urgency creates natural clarity.

Limit your options. The paradox of choice is real. Instead of considering 15 possibilities, narrow it down to your top 3. This isn't being lazy; it's being strategic.

Trust your gut, then verify with logic. Your intuition processes more information than your conscious mind ever could. If something feels right, there's usually a good reason. Use logic to double-check, not to override.

Remember that most decisions are reversible. You're not choosing a life partner here; you're choosing a business direction. If it doesn't work out, you'll figure something else out. You always do.

What Brisbane's Top CEOs Know About Fast Decisions

The most successful executives I work with share one trait: they make decisions quickly and change them slowly. They understand that perfect is the enemy of good, and good is the enemy of done.

I remember working with a tech startup founder who was struggling to choose between two potential investors. Both offered similar terms, both had good track records. Instead of agonising for weeks, she made a simple decision: she went with the one who responded to emails faster. Her reasoning? "If they're this responsive during courtship, they'll probably be more engaged as partners."

That company is now valued at $12 million.

The Indecision Epidemic in Australian Workplaces

We've somehow convinced ourselves that taking time to decide makes us look thoughtful and responsible. But here's what it actually signals: that you lack confidence in your own judgement. Your team picks up on this uncertainty, and it becomes contagious.

I've seen entire organisations paralysed because their leaders can't make basic operational decisions. Staff become frustrated, innovation stagnates, and competitors gain ground while you're still "evaluating options."

It's particularly noticeable in government-adjacent roles where people are terrified of being wrong. But in the private sector, being wrong quickly is infinitely better than being right slowly.

The Surprising Power of Flipping a Coin

This sounds ridiculous, but bear with me. When facing a truly difficult decision, flip a coin. Not because the coin will decide for you, but because in the moment it's in the air, you'll know which outcome you're hoping for.

Your subconscious already knows what you want to do. The indecision is just your conscious mind creating interference. Sometimes you need a silly ritual to get out of your own way.

Why Perfectionist Leaders Fail

I used to be one of those leaders who needed every detail nailed down before moving forward. It nearly cost me my business. While I was perfecting my service offering, three competitors launched similar programs and carved up the market.

Perfectionism isn't about high standards; it's about fear of judgement. You'd rather be seen as thorough than risk being seen as wrong. But in business, being wrong and learning is better than being paralysed and irrelevant.

The companies that dominate markets aren't the ones with perfect strategies; they're the ones willing to test, adapt, and improve while their competitors are still planning.

Making Peace with "Good Enough" Decisions

This doesn't mean being careless or reckless. It means accepting that most business decisions can be adjusted, improved, or even completely reversed if they don't work out. The cost of a potentially wrong decision is usually far less than the cost of delayed action.

I think about it like this: if you're driving from Melbourne to Sydney and you miss a turn, you don't abandon the journey. You recalculate and keep moving. Business decisions work the same way.

The Bottom Line

Indecisiveness isn't a character flaw; it's a learned behaviour that can be unlearned. The best decision-makers aren't those who never make mistakes – they're those who make decisions quickly, learn from the outcomes, and adjust accordingly.

Your competition isn't waiting for you to feel ready. Your market isn't pausing while you seek more opinions. Your opportunities aren't holding their breath until you've reached perfect certainty.

Sometimes the biggest risk is not taking any risk at all. Stop overthinking. Start deciding. Your future self will thank you for it.

Looking to improve your decision-making skills? Check out these resources: